Yes, everything is stupid right now, including that every few hours it feels like another system has broken. In just the last week we’ve had Microsoft web services go down, the FAA comms system collapse (supposedly due to a contractor’s router flooding the network during a routine upgrade?), bank websites go down, United Airlines systems go down, a bunch of tech companies (including Zoom and Salesforce) get exploited via Optimizely, Apple’s iCloud go down, and even the NSA’s super duper top secret network go down. Of all these, only the Optimizely mess appears to definitely be an exploitation, though many people are asking questions about the rest.
It should be no surprise that people are also connecting the dots and wondering if these things are all connected. I mean, how could you not? For what it’s worth, I tend to agree with the experts Prof. Kate Klonick has spoken to who suggest the most likely explanation is a benign one — old systems do break down, and it can be a bit of a coincidence that a bunch of big-name systems all broke down around the same time, but humans (as pattern-matching animals) are just paying closer attention to all of them breaking down at once.
If there is a throughline here, my guess is that a lot of the tech companies have been quick to push layoffs lately, stupidly believing that they can replace people with AI (which, as we’ve been saying, is a dumb plan), and that means a lot of expertise — including the kind of tacit knowledge AI can’t easily capture — has walked out the door. When the people who actually know how to keep these old systems running are gone, those systems become a bit more likely to fail. That is, while lots of people jumped to “AI” being to blame, my guess (and it is a guess) is that it’s less the direct impact of AI systems, and much more the downstream indirect results of stupid CEOs cutting corners by laying off the kind of people who could keep these systems online.
Still, it does no one any favors to have the dumbest fucking people alive in charge of all of this, but we do. Back on Friday when the FAA ground stop situation happened, the first one to talk about it was DHS Secretary Markwayne Mullin (who, back when he was a senator, was long considered one of the dumbest people in the Senate). When asked if the FAA situations had anything to do with AI he responded by refusing to rule it out (“You just can’t rule out anything at this point”) and with the absolutely ridiculous retort: “We call it SI around here, remember?” He also said that it wasn’t “another 9/11” which is an awfully odd comparison to make, and only served to make many people wonder if we should be even more worried.
Later that evening he appeared next to Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy, where there were awkward exchanges where Duffy and Mullin didn’t appear to be on the same page about what happened or what was to blame. However, both the FAA and the contractor behind its newly expanded $875 million AI system insisted that system had nothing to do with it.
Then, on Monday evening Mullin went on Sean Hannity’s show and… reminded everyone just how clueless he still is. The video clips are remarkable, mainly this one that shows him first suggesting that all the outages don’t appear to be a cyberattack, based on his conversations with CISA, and then saying how he spoke to some successful tech bro who he says asked not to be named (though he says it’s not Elon) who fed him some nonsense that, once it makes it through the empty caverns of Mullin’s brain, came out even more garbled:
Mullin mentions that he had the folks at CISA (the Cybersecurity & Infrastructure Security Agency) look into all of these events, and they told him that it doesn’t appear to be an interrelated cyberattack.
“[W]hen we start looking at the cyber world, I start asking CISA, hey, what’s going on here? And they said, sir, we’re not seeing any traffic that would make us think that this is a cyberattack, they’re all individually unrelated.”
First up, mentioning CISA is fascinating, given that MAGA’s conspiracy theory-level false belief that CISA engaged in “censorship of conservatives” meant that many MAGA Republicans wanted to kill the entire agency. Even though that didn’t happen, there were massive cuts. Also, as we’ve previously reported, the second Trump Administration was so obsessed with their false belief regarding the work CISA did that froze a bunch of the infrastructure security work it did, and instead moved those infrastructure security experts into roles processing deportation paperwork.
Yes, that’s right, the federal government gutted its cybersecurity infrastructure staff and put many of those who remained on “deportation paperwork processing” instead. And that hollowed-out agency is the one we’re now relying on to tell us everything’s fine.
Anyway, the next bit of Mullin’s ramblings to Hannity is just absolutely bizarre:
“And so I started talking to the tech industry, and one guy that’s very smart with tech…it’s not Elon…I said, what could be causing all these separate outages, and he says, I believe that it’s the SI. He said because these programs aren’t designed to work as fast as SI is, and so, when they…put in a program that’s able to write codes, and it goes in, it self-fixes itself, as it starts self-fixing itself, it’s like doing a change order on a house. When you change one thing in a house, everything else starts changing, and it’s a ripple effect, and it causes these systems to be over[run] that weren’t designed to run as fast as the SI technology is today. That was the conversation I had today. That kind of makes sense to me.”
Sooooooo… you can kinda piece together what someone probably told Mullin if we backtrack it through the reverse-stupid filter. From Mullin’s description, it sounds like someone explained to him what recursive self-improvement (RSI) means (“self-fixing”) and he then tried to apply that to the outages? Except that RSI is on the training new models side of things, not the keeping basic infrastructure working side of things. The whole “work as fast as” and “self-fixing” thing really sounds very much like someone who was told a few things about how AI systems work and are trained and not understanding the technology even slightly, and regurgitating it to the press in the stupidest way possible.
Also, dude, you’re the Secretary of Homeland Security, speaking to “one guy that’s very smart with tech” is not exactly the way you should be going around trying to get a handle on what’s happening with our technology systems these days.
As mentioned, it’s very possible AI played an indirect role here, and some of these outages may even have more direct AI-related causes. But so far almost everyone involved has denied that AI tools had anything to do with it, so it’s not very reassuring when the Homeland Security Secretary who goes around saying “this is not another 9/11” also decides to call up random tech bros to get their take, which he will then explain badly in a manner that doesn’t make much sense. There may be more to all of this, but I have zero faith that Mullin would either understand or be able to explain to the public what AI’s role was.
At this point, I am way less worried about all these system outages (and I say that as someone who got stranded 3,000 miles from home for five days due to the FAA mess, and am writing about this on the first flight I could finally get back towards home many days later) than I am about the fact that we really have the dumbest, most credulous, conspiracy-theory believing dipshits in charge of any sort of coordinated response to all of these outages.
A thread on the internet suddenly going to hell 

